What We Mean When We Say Something Is “Well-Written”

“Well-written” is one of the most reliable compliments a piece of writing can receive. It appears in reviews, in feedback, in the recommendations readers pass along to each other. This is well-written. The phrase carries genuine praise — the person using it means something positive, something admiring. They are not being vague on purpose.

And yet “well-written” is, as a description, almost entirely empty. It tells us that the reader responded positively to the writing. It tells us nothing about what the writing actually did.

Continue reading “What We Mean When We Say Something Is “Well-Written”” →

How I Handle Feedback on My Writing

Feedback on writing is one of the more complicated things a writer has to manage — not because it is difficult to receive criticism, though it can be, but because not all feedback is equally useful and acting on the wrong feedback can make a piece worse rather than better. The writer who treats all feedback as equally valid, and revises accordingly, tends to produce a piece that pleases no one and reflects nothing.

The useful skill is not the ability to receive feedback without defensiveness — though that is worth developing — but the ability to evaluate it: to distinguish feedback that identifies a real problem from feedback that identifies a preference, and to know which to act on and which to set aside.

Continue reading “How I Handle Feedback on My Writing” →