Tag: writing process

The First Draft Problem

~ Silver Threads ~ Leave a comment

The first draft has a problem that most writing advice obscures: it is not a draft of the piece. It is a draft of the thinking. And thinking, in its early stages, is neither coherent nor presentable. It circles, qualifies, contradicts itself, arrives at the wrong place, and occasionally surprises the writer by going somewhere better than intended.

This is not a malfunction of the first draft. It is the first draft doing exactly what it is supposed to do. The problem arises when writers mistake the first draft for something it is not — for a preliminary version of the final piece, which will be corrected into shape. A preliminary version of the final piece would only require editing. What most first drafts actually require is a reckoning.

Continue reading “The First Draft Problem” →

How I Approach Revision

~ Silver Threads ~ Leave a comment

Revising writing is not the same as editing it. The distinction matters because confusing the two leads to a particular kind of failure: a piece that is technically clean — no grammatical errors, no awkward sentences — but still not working. The sentences are correct. The piece is not right.

Editing is the process of making a piece technically correct. Revision is the process of making it true — not factually accurate, necessarily, but true in the sense of being what it set out to be. A revised piece has earned its conclusion. Its argument has been tested and held. Its structure serves the thinking rather than constraining it. These are different achievements from a piece that has been merely edited, and they require different work.

Continue reading “How I Approach Revision” →

Writing as Discovery — I Don’t Write Because I Know

~ Silver Threads ~ Leave a comment

Writing as discovery is not a technique. It is not a method you choose, the way you might choose a structure or a style. It is something you either trust or you don’t — and most writers, at least early in their practice, don’t.

I used to assume that writing required certainty. That before I sat down to begin, I should already know what I believed, what I wanted to say, and where the argument would land. The page, I thought, was for articulation, not discovery. You worked out the thinking first, and then you wrote it down.

Experience has taught me otherwise.

Continue reading “Writing as Discovery — I Don’t Write Because I Know” →

What I Do Before I Write a Word

~ Silver Threads ~ Leave a comment

Before you write a word, there is a set of decisions that will determine whether the writing goes well or poorly. Not the writing itself — the thinking that precedes it. Most writers skip this stage, or compress it into a few minutes of vague intention, and then wonder why the draft stalls, repeats itself, or arrives somewhere other than where it was supposed to go.

This framework applies to purposeful writing — pieces with a defined brief, audience, and destination. Exploratory writing is a different practice, and a different conversation.

Continue reading “What I Do Before I Write a Word” →

The Editing Passes I Use Before a Draft Is Done

~ Silver Threads ~ Leave a comment

Editing a draft is not a single act. Most writers who struggle with revision treat it as one — they read through what they have written, change things as they notice them, and declare the piece done when they run out of things to change. The result is a draft that is tidier than it was, but not necessarily better.

The problem is that different editing tasks require different kinds of attention. Structural problems are invisible when you are looking for word-level errors. Tonal inconsistencies are hard to hear when you are checking facts. Trying to do everything in a single pass means doing nothing particularly well.

Continue reading “The Editing Passes I Use Before a Draft Is Done” →